I think that re-posting a response originally made 15-months ago, and saying that is “our latest response” really points out the problem. The response is so ironic it’s funny.
3 Likes
There is no change to the response because currently there is no update, we will have more news soon, but cannot fabricate what has not happened yet.
The BBM 2 is our next big goal, autopilot is still in our sights.
Thank you for your feedback and your patience
I still find the whole concept of autopilot not that far removed from OPB. I get it. It’s like OPB with an escape valve, and, as such, autopilot is an appropriate name. You can override an autopilot action and have the song act like a segmented song. So, where might one use this? The two obvious example are to vamp an intro until the singer is ready, and to take an extra chorus for a song that the crowd is “into.” It could also work for jams. Implementation of this is not a straightforward process. The intro vamp is not a current segmented song process. It’s essentially an initial main loop. The chorus seems easier. But, as much as I have seen users beg for autopilot, these uses seem secondary. What seems to get the most clamor is for a simple roadmap for the current Premium Library. There is no reason that Singular cannot provide that NOW. It requires no programming or development. Goran has the notes. Let’s get that info out now. You’ll calm down many of the complaints. The other issues can be handled with the current BBM, if we have the roadmaps.
8 Likes
Phil_Flood’s comment is spot. Publishing roadmaps for the existing premium content would at least make it useful for current users, myself included, and would ease the wait.
4 Likes
Sorry but it always seems like we get off topic.
I believe the issue overall is the Beat Buddy Managers inability to meet the basic needs of the users(musicians).
The capabilities we are asking for are years behind what technology is capable of.
This is basic stuff. As consumers of your product we expect more.
Where should I spend my hard-earned money?
I want support Singular Sound. If I didn’t then I wouldn’t waste my time.
If the BBM software is that bad then start over. Don’t try to fix a cracked foundation.
This is not rocket science but still we wait for years. It’s all about priorities.
To be honest…why would I buy more products from a company that wont support what I already own?
6 Likes
Well I look forward to the next email from SS being an announcement about that then and not about the Aeros. I’m not holding my breath …
I’ll respond to the question as to why I haven’t posted the BB song roadmaps public.
There are several reasons for that.
The “charts” that I have were created for a specific purpose and were constructed in a manner to facilitate that purpose, which is the creation of drum parts and arranging them into BB songs. They were meant for my use only. Those charts are different from how they would have been done if I were to play them live, in real-time, on an acoustic drumset, which may still be different from how I would notate them for others to use.
In addition to myself, another three people did drum transcriptions for me. While I provided the exact specifications on how they should be done, many of them were done differently. So, they are not consistent. Some charts show how many times a section should be played, while others show how many times a drum part should be repeated. I know the styles of each transcriber, so I can tell what’s what.
When I first started creating the drum charts for the songs, I didn’t notate the lengths of sections, as there was no talk of AP then.
Realistically, if you were to hire a pro drummer to read those drum charts and press the pedal for you in real-time while you play your instrument, they would have a hard time doing that in most cases. Two of my assistants spent months deciphering and programming those scribbles into the unfinished BBM autopilot.
So, while some charts may be somewhat helpful, you won’t know what you are looking at and how to begin with, others. You won’t see how some parts were actually accomplished in MIDI and loaded into the BB. Some parts were glued together, while others stayed separate. This may lead to further disappointment and frustration.
I think they would be a waste of time, and that’s why I haven’t posted them. So, now that you know what they are let me know if you still want me to post them. To be perfectly clear, I do NOT offer any guarantee and will NOT provide any guidance or explain anything with regards to them.
Let me know.
1 Like
I’d like to have them. If nothing else it will help me to understand how difficult it will be to implement the whole autopilot process.
1 Like
Cheers for the detailed explanation @GoranGrooves,
I would be also interested with a similar motivation as @Phil_Flood …
Cheers,
Wolf
I agree, “Cheers for the detailed explanation”. Thanks Goran!
One thought that does occur to me is that the “community” might in some fashion take in the originals, massage them, and ultimately create a more standardized and accessible set of charts for general use. Based on that possibility, even having the charts as hieroglyphics could be a valid starting point, as the original songs themselves (the audio) would be a guide to decyphering them.
Having a background in programming, I find this to be a fascinating sentence: “Two of my assistants spent months deciphering and programming those scribbles into the unfinished BBM autopilot.”
What was the result here? Lists? Tables? Data files? - representing the structures of the songs … (?)
None of these would normally be put up on a music stand for a gig, but to users familiar with programming the BB and thinking in terms of sections and repeats etc. such formats might actually be quite straightforward to understand structurally.
To me, the -structures- of the songs are very interesting - perhaps as much or more than the the “hits” or “beats” of the original drum parts per se. The structures could be replicated (and/or tweaked/varied) with any available hits or beats used as subs for the originals and thus become the foundations for new jams. Any library-like starting point for such efforts is much to be desired!
I was thinking something similar along these lines. In fact, if there are other users who have already tried to string together the parts of the Premium Content into an OPB for a particular song, that would be most helpful to have as a guide. From experience, I can tell you that I generally was able to figure out what was going on with the “Main Loops”, but the timing for the fills was not easily discerned. If we were able to collaborate on developing useful roadmaps, that would be a big plus.
2 Likes
@GoranGrooves Thanks. That’s interesting. I don’t use the Premium Library myself, but I’d be interested to know one thing, if you’re willing to say. In the absence of road maps, how were you thinking the users would use the song packs? Were you thinking that users would know the originals sufficiently well to work out when parts changed and fills occurred by listening to the original recordings?
2 Likes
1st thing I thought too.
1 Like
That’s what I’ve done. It’s usually pretty simple to listen in and figure out what’s what. I don’t have the full premium, but have purchased 20-30 tunes, along with building some on my own out of the standard beats. It’s usually not terrible to figure out what the drum parts are. Sometimes though there are like 15-20 drum parts along with various fills and that does get tedious. It helps that some of the drum parts are named helpfully, while others aren’t so much.
I’ve also found some issues, like with Purple Rain. There’s a 6/4 part that’s just not there. The whole song is in 4/4 and I’ve not found a way to make it work. So I modified it myself to have it in there, and basically built a 1 press file out of it.
I’m pretty tech savvy though, and have been playing/studying music for 30 years, so YMMV.
1 Like
I would not hold your breath waiting for a NEW or UPGRADED BeatBuddy Manager. I have, like you, been singing about “where’s the support” for years. I know my words will get up the nose of many users but as so many BB owners use third party midi programming platforms to build their files Singular Sound has just basically said “why should we spend the time and money to improve or develop a new BBM” which to me seems like a real cop out on the companies support to their primary product. They did promise such a thing was coming for a couple of years, but nothing came of it. It does appear they dedicate all their tech energy to newer devices and software. How very Apple of them.
2 Likes
Agreed. I think the important part that SS is missing……
I will not buy another product from them and will not recommend them.
Maybe it doesn’t matter but they could have been more successful.
Too bad.
1 Like
I also will not buy another product or midi file from them until SS fulfils their years old promise to improve the BBM. It is truly something out of the 1980’s. Even a Copy/Paste function would improve it 1000%. I am flat-out getting it to not crash when I edit a pattern. Last song I wrote files for on my MacBook BBM crashed twenty two times during the two days over which I finished writing parts as they were a bit elaborate. As a result I am using the BeatBuddy less and more fully written backing tracks I assemble in Logic X with Superior Drummer. I have never been able to successfully copy a Superior drummer midi file across to the BeatBuddy either so I don’t even try anymore. We can only hope.
Yes. I expected users to be familiar with the songs, and triggering sections would be instinctual. Unfortunately, some songs are way too complex to achieve that, and the only practical way is to have them programmed (hence autopilot).
While many of you have requested particular songs to be replicated for the BB use, both you and I have gradually come to the same conclusion. While I may produce the beats and the original forms, performing some content live will be impractical, if not impossible. I have no interest in creating content that is useless to you any more than you are interested in buying such content.
For the time being, I shifted my focus to creating more generic content that is more accessible for everyone to play and will serve a greater purpose to more BB users.
Anyhow, here are the charts I mentioned I have in my possession.
A couple of things worth noting: once the AP is available (and assuming I am still alive by that point), we’ll get all of the existing premium songs programmed to work with it. So, you won’t need to be doing that yourself.
The way I specified charting for BB AP would involve a straight transfer of values from the charts to the AP interface. Unfortunately, one of the transcribers I used did not follow my specs strictly, so that’s why the charts are inconsistent.
4 Likes
Thanks so much @GoranGrooves,
I’m just trying to create a couple of OPB’s from my Premium Content & this will be ever so helpful …
Many thanks again 
:
Wolf
Thank you Goran for a most excellent contribution!
Here’s hoping someday we’ll have the Autopilot available to do all that is intended for it.